Pima County, AZ

A G E N D A

PIMA COUNTY

PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION

REGULAR MEETING

JANUARY 31, 2001

AT OR AFTER 9:00 A.M.

Public Works Building, 201 North Stone Avenue

Basement - Meeting Rooms "C" and "D"

SCHEDULE

8:30 A.M. BRIEFING

Conference Room ‘D’

9:00 A.M. REGULAR SESSION

Conference Room ‘C’

Consent Agenda

Subdivision Variances

Comprehensive Plan Amendments for Continued Public Hearing

Rezonings for Continued Public Hearing

Waivers of the Platting Requirements for New Public Hearing

Modification (Substantial Changes) of Specific Plan Requirements for New Public Hearing

Rezonings for New Public Hearing

Old Business

New Business

Call to the Audience

SPEAKING PROCEDURE

1. All speakers will position themselves so they can approach the podium as quickly as possible.

Please submit speaker’s cards to the Commission Recording Secretary.

2. Those wishing to speak must sign in and state name and address.

3. The applicant will speak first and limit presentation to 15 minutes. The applicant may request and may be granted additional time if Commission is notified prior to public hearing.

4. Individual speakers from the audience will have five minutes each to present testimony. The Commission requests that they not be repetitive. When there is a large group wishing to speak, it will be appreciated if one or two persons could represent the group. They may request and be granted additional time if the Commission Recording Secretary is notified prior to public hearing.

5. The applicant will then have five minutes to rebut points raised.

6. Public hearing will then be closed and debate will be limited to Commission and staff.

7. Commission votes on motion and the outcome is announced.

****************************************************************************************************

REGULAR MEETING AGENDA

1) CALL TO ORDER 9:00 A.M.

ROLL CALL:

( ) Thomas Spendiarian, Chairman ( ) William Matter

( ) Stephen Prater, Vice-Chair ( ) Armando Membrila

( ) Sharon L. Barry ( ) William Staples

( ) Bruce Gungle ( ) Priscilla Storm

( ) William Hausman ( ) Charles Willsey

2) PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

3) CONSENT AGENDA

B-123 APPROVAL OF DECEMBER 2000 CHECKLIST

B-218 COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR'S REPORT FOR DECEMBER, 2000

B-940 MONTHLY REPORTS TO THE P/Z COMMISSION

Memorandum to the Commission regarding departmental case load, case disposition, appeals to the County Boards of Adjustment, new cases, rezoning actions, project status and actions taken by the Planning and Zoning Commission and the Board of Supervisors.

4A) B-1200 SUBDIVISION VARIANCES (CONTINUED REQUESTS)

Materials prepared for the Commission from the Development Services Department, Planning Division, regarding variances for tentative subdivision plats for consideration.

P1200-160 CAMINO DEL RIO ESTATES

The request is for a variance for the "Camino Del Rio Estates, Lots 1-40" project that will allow two cul-de-sacs that each exceed the 1,000 feet maximum length (1,438 feet and 1,468 feet respectively) and the two cul-de-sacs collectively service 40 lots. Since the two proposed cul-de-sacs have the same access point, the total number of lots serviced exceed the 22 lot maximum. Due to the existing topography, a loop street and a second access point is not feasible.

a) Staff Report

b) Applicant Presentation/Continued Hearing

c) Action

4B) B-1200 SUBDIVISION VARIANCES (NEW REQUESTS)

Materials prepared for the Commission from the Development Services Department, Planning Division, regarding variances for tentative subdivision plats for consideration.

No cases to date.

COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT

FOR CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING

5) Co7-00-14 CONGREGATION CHAVERIM - E. RIVER ROAD

Request of Carl Winters, Planning Resources, representing Congregation Chaverim, to amend the Pima County Comprehensive Plan from Low Intensity Urban 1.2 (LIU 1.2) to Medium Intensity Urban (MIU). The subject property is approximately 1.0 acre and is located northeast of East River Road and Via Entrada, approximately 1/3 mile west of Campbell Avenue in the Catalina Foothills Subregion. (District 1)

a) Staff Report

b) Applicant Presentation/Continued Public Hearing

c) Action

REZONINGS FOR CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING

6) Co9-00-15 MESSINGER/LEWIN FAMILY LLC - CORTARO FARMS ROAD REZONING

Request of Messinger/Lewin Family LLC, represented by The Planning Center, for a rezoning of 64.93 acres from SR (Suburban Ranch) and SH (Suburban Homestead) to CR-4 (Mixed-Dwelling Type), located on the south side of Cortaro Farms Road, approximately 3/4 mile east of Interstate 10. The request lies within and conforms to the Pima County Comprehensive Plan, Co7-89-2. (District 3)

a) Staff Report

b) Applicant Presentation/Continued Public Hearing

c) Action

7) Co9-00-06 GOLDER - ORACLE ROAD #3 REZONING

Request of Lloyd Golder, represented by George Holguin, for a rezoning of 5.23 acres from GR-1 (Rural Residential) to CB-1 (Local Business), located on the east side of Oracle Road, approximately 1/4 mile south of Rollins Road. The request lies within and conforms to the Pima County Comprehensive Plan, Co7-89-2. (District 3)

a) Staff Report

b) Applicant Presentation/Continued Public Hearing

c) Action

8) Co9-00-51 SOBLE/STEWART TITLE & TRUST #0801 - CAMINO LOMA ALTA REZONING

Request of Soble/Stewart Title & Trust #0801,represented by Custom Builders Realty & Development Co., L.L.C., for a rezoning of 28 acres from GR-1 (Rural Residential) to CR-2 (Single Residence) and CR-3 (Single Residence), located 1/4 mile north of Colossal Cave Road on the east side of Camino Loma Alta. The proposed rezoning conforms to the Pima County Comprehensive Plan Co7-89-2. (District 4)

a) Staff Report

b) Applicant Presentation/Continued Public Hearing

c) Action

WAIVERS OF THE PLATTING REQUIREMENT

FOR NEW PUBLIC HEARING

9) Co9-00-61 BUDA - COLUMBUS BOULEVARD #3 REZONING

Request of Michael and Sandra Buda for a waiver of the platting requirement of the Lago Del Oro Zoning Plan. The applicant requests a rezoning of 1.02 acres from GR-1 (Rural Residence) to SH (Suburban Homestead), located on the east side of Columbus Boulevard (Catalina), approximately 400 feet north of Pinto Lane. The proposed rezoning conforms to the Lago Del Oro Zoning Plan Co13-63-17B and the Pima County Comprehensive Plan Co7-89-2. (District 3)

a) Staff Report

b) Applicant Presentation/Public Hearing

c) Action

MODIFICIATIONS (SUBSTANTIAL CHANGES) OF REZONING CONDITIONS

FOR NEW PUBLIC HEARING

10) Co9-62-04 COPELAND - ORACLE ROAD REZONING

Request of Fidelity National Title Agency TR 30,038, represented by The WLB Group Inc., for a modification (substantial change) of rezoning condition #1, which requires a 50-foot building setback from the western boundary of the rezoning site. The applicant proposes to delete the 50-foot setback requirement for Lot #23 of Panorama Ridge Estates. The subject lot is 5,390 square feet of a larger rezoning in 1963 to CR-4 and is located on the south side of Panorama Vista Drive, approximately 600 feet south of Panorama Road and 1000 feet west of Oracle Road. (District 1)

a) Staff Report

b) Applicant Presentation/Public Hearing

c) Action

REZONINGS FOR NEW PUBLIC HEARING

11) Co9-00-58 FIDELITY NATIONAL TITLE #30056 - MORRILL WAY REZONING

Request of Fidelity National Title #30056, represented by Mac Summer, for a rezoning of 4.88 acres from SR (Suburban Ranch) to CR-1 (Single Residence), located on the north side of Morrill Way, 1/8-mile west of Catalina Highway. The proposed rezoning conforms to the Pima County Comprehensive Plan Co7-89-2, but does not conform to the Agua Caliente-Sabino Creek Zoning Plan. (District 4)

a) Staff Report

b) Applicant Presentation/Public Hearing

c) Action

12) Co9-0-64 MYERS - CAMINO DE OESTE #2 REZONING

Request of H. Lee Myers, represented by James Rossi, for a rezoning of 0.91 acres from CR-1 (Single Residence) to CR-3 (Single Residence), located on the west side of Camino de Oeste, approximately 500 feet north of Cortaro Farms Road. The proposed rezoning conforms to the Pima County Comprehensive Plan Co7-89-2. (District 3)

a) Staff Report

b) Applicant Presentation/Public Hearing

c) Action

13) OLD BUSINESS

A. Discussion/Action On Commissioner Gungle’s Request for Legal Advice regarding Comprehensive Plan Amendments.

14) NEW BUSINESS

15) CALL TO THE AUDIENCE

16) ADJOURNMENT

			A G E N D A PIMA COUNTY PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING JANUARY 31, 2001 AT OR AFTER 9:00 A.M. Public Works Building, 201 North Stone Avenue Basement - Meeting Rooms "C" and "D" SCHEDULE 8:30 A.M. BRIEFING Conference Room ‘D’ 9:00 A.M. REGULAR SESSION Conference Room ‘C’ Consent Agenda Subdivision Variances Comprehensive Plan Amendments for Continued Public Hearing Rezonings for Continued Public Hearing Waivers of the Platting Requirements for New Public Hearing Modification (Substantial Changes) of Specific Plan Requirements for New Public Hearing Rezonings for New Public Hearing Old Business New Business Call to the Audience SPEAKING PROCEDURE 1. All speakers will position themselves so they can approach the podium as quickly as possible. Please submit speaker’s cards to the Commission Recording Secretary. 2. Those wishing to speak must sign in and state name and address. 3. The applicant will speak first and limit presentation to 15 minutes. The applicant may request and may be granted additional time if Commission is notified prior to public hearing. 4. Individual speakers from the audience will have five minutes each to present testimony. The Commission requests that they not be repetitive. When there is a large group wishing to speak, it will be appreciated if one or two persons could represent the group. They may request and be granted additional time if the Commission Recording Secretary is notified prior to public hearing. 5. The applicant will then have five minutes to rebut points raised. 6. Public hearing will then be closed and debate will be limited to Commission and staff. 7. Commission votes on motion and the outcome is announced. ************************************************************************************************** REGULAR MEETING AGENDA 1) CALL TO ORDER 9:00 A.M. ROLL CALL: ( ) Thomas Spendiarian, Chairman ( ) William Matter ( ) Stephen Prater, Vice-Chair ( ) Armando Membrila ( ) Sharon L. Barry ( ) William Staples ( ) Bruce Gungle ( ) Priscilla Storm ( ) William Hausman ( ) Charles Willsey 2) PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 3) CONSENT AGENDA B-123 APPROVAL OF DECEMBER 2000 CHECKLIST B-218 COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR'S REPORT FOR DECEMBER, 2000 B-940 MONTHLY REPORTS TO THE P/Z COMMISSION Memorandum to the Commission regarding departmental case load, case disposition, appeals to the County Boards of Adjustment, new cases, rezoning actions, project status and actions taken by the Planning and Zoning Commission and the Board of Supervisors. 4A) B-1200 SUBDIVISION VARIANCES (CONTINUED REQUESTS) Materials prepared for the Commission from the Development Services Department, Planning Division, regarding variances for tentative subdivision plats for consideration. P1200-160 CAMINO DEL RIO ESTATES The request is for a variance for the "Camino Del Rio Estates, Lots 1-40" project that will allow two cul-de-sacs that each exceed the 1,000 feet maximum length (1,438 feet and 1,468 feet respectively) and the two cul-de-sacs collectively service 40 lots. Since the two proposed cul-de-sacs have the same access point, the total number of lots serviced exceed the 22 lot maximum. Due to the existing topography, a loop street and a second access point is not feasible. a) Staff Report b) Applicant Presentation/Continued Hearing c) Action 4B) B-1200 SUBDIVISION VARIANCES (NEW REQUESTS) Materials prepared for the Commission from the Development Services Department, Planning Division, regarding variances for tentative subdivision plats for consideration. No cases to date. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT FOR CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING 5) Co7-00-14 CONGREGATION CHAVERIM - E. RIVER ROAD Request of Carl Winters, Planning Resources, representing Congregation Chaverim, to amend the Pima County Comprehensive Plan from Low Intensity Urban 1.2 (LIU 1.2) to Medium Intensity Urban (MIU). The subject property is approximately 1.0 acre and is located northeast of East River Road and Via Entrada, approximately 1/3 mile west of Campbell Avenue in the Catalina Foothills Subregion. (District 1) a) Staff Report b) Applicant Presentation/Continued Public Hearing c) Action REZONINGS FOR CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING 6) Co9-00-15 MESSINGER/LEWIN FAMILY LLC - CORTARO FARMS ROAD REZONING Request of Messinger/Lewin Family LLC, represented by The Planning Center, for a rezoning of 64.93 acres from SR (Suburban Ranch) and SH (Suburban Homestead) to CR-4 (Mixed-Dwelling Type), located on the south side of Cortaro Farms Road, approximately 3/4 mile east of Interstate 10. The request lies within and conforms to the Pima County Comprehensive Plan, Co7-89-2. (District 3) a) Staff Report b) Applicant Presentation/Continued Public Hearing c) Action 7) Co9-00-06 GOLDER - ORACLE ROAD #3 REZONING Request of Lloyd Golder, represented by George Holguin, for a rezoning of 5.23 acres from GR-1 (Rural Residential) to CB-1 (Local Business), located on the east side of Oracle Road, approximately 1/4 mile south of Rollins Road. The request lies within and conforms to the Pima County Comprehensive Plan, Co7-89-2. (District 3) a) Staff Report b) Applicant Presentation/Continued Public Hearing c) Action 8) Co9-00-51 SOBLE/STEWART TITLE & TRUST #0801 - CAMINO LOMA ALTA REZONING Request of Soble/Stewart Title & Trust #0801,represented by Custom Builders Realty & Development Co., L.L.C., for a rezoning of 28 acres from GR-1 (Rural Residential) to CR-2 (Single Residence) and CR-3 (Single Residence), located 1/4 mile north of Colossal Cave Road on the east side of Camino Loma Alta. The proposed rezoning conforms to the Pima County Comprehensive Plan Co7-89-2. (District 4) a) Staff Report b) Applicant Presentation/Continued Public Hearing c) Action WAIVERS OF THE PLATTING REQUIREMENT FOR NEW PUBLIC HEARING 9) Co9-00-61 BUDA - COLUMBUS BOULEVARD #3 REZONING Request of Michael and Sandra Buda for a waiver of the platting requirement of the Lago Del Oro Zoning Plan. The applicant requests a rezoning of 1.02 acres from GR-1 (Rural Residence) to SH (Suburban Homestead), located on the east side of Columbus Boulevard (Catalina), approximately 400 feet north of Pinto Lane. The proposed rezoning conforms to the Lago Del Oro Zoning Plan Co13-63-17B and the Pima County Comprehensive Plan Co7-89-2. (District 3) a) Staff Report b) Applicant Presentation/Public Hearing c) Action MODIFICIATIONS (SUBSTANTIAL CHANGES) OF REZONING CONDITIONS FOR NEW PUBLIC HEARING 10) Co9-62-04 COPELAND - ORACLE ROAD REZONING Request of Fidelity National Title Agency TR 30,038, represented by The WLB Group Inc., for a modification (substantial change) of rezoning condition #1, which requires a 50-foot building setback from the western boundary of the rezoning site. The applicant proposes to delete the 50-foot setback requirement for Lot #23 of Panorama Ridge Estates. The subject lot is 5,390 square feet of a larger rezoning in 1963 to CR-4 and is located on the south side of Panorama Vista Drive, approximately 600 feet south of Panorama Road and 1000 feet west of Oracle Road. (District 1) a) Staff Report b) Applicant Presentation/Public Hearing c) Action REZONINGS FOR NEW PUBLIC HEARING 11) Co9-00-58 FIDELITY NATIONAL TITLE #30056 - MORRILL WAY REZONING Request of Fidelity National Title #30056, represented by Mac Summer, for a rezoning of 4.88 acres from SR (Suburban Ranch) to CR-1 (Single Residence), located on the north side of Morrill Way, 1/8-mile west of Catalina Highway. The proposed rezoning conforms to the Pima County Comprehensive Plan Co7-89-2, but does not conform to the Agua Caliente-Sabino Creek Zoning Plan. (District 4) a) Staff Report b) Applicant Presentation/Public Hearing c) Action 12) Co9-0-64 MYERS - CAMINO DE OESTE #2 REZONING Request of H. Lee Myers, represented by James Rossi, for a rezoning of 0.91 acres from CR-1 (Single Residence) to CR-3 (Single Residence), located on the west side of Camino de Oeste, approximately 500 feet north of Cortaro Farms Road. The proposed rezoning conforms to the Pima County Comprehensive Plan Co7-89-2. (District 3) a) Staff Report b) Applicant Presentation/Public Hearing c) Action 13) OLD BUSINESS A. Discussion/Action On Commissioner Gungle’s Request for Legal Advice regarding Comprehensive Plan Amendments. 14) NEW BUSINESS 15) CALL TO THE AUDIENCE 16) ADJOURNMENT**